ETFs were historically associated with passive strategies. But regulatory changes in 2019 made it easier for managers to introduce and oversee active ETFs. This led to a proliferation of active strategies packaged in a tax-efficient ETF wrapper. (The way ETF shares are created and redeemed can help limit capital gains distributions.) Four years later, 2023 may go down as the year that active ETF inflows really started to take off.

If you’re considering using active ETFs, you may have questions about their maturity. We break down some of the biggest trends in active ETFs and what advisors should watch going forward.

Active ETFs earned nearly a quarter of 2023 flows

Passively managed ETFs have a much longer history and, therefore, most of the assets. Active ETFs account for about 6% of the roughly $7.2 trillion overall U.S. ETF market.¹ But active ETF assets have risen 44% year-over-year to $439 billion despite a volatile market environment.¹

It’s the organic growth trends of active and passive ETFs, however, that jump off the page. Active ETFs have accounted for about 24% of all ETF flows year to date.¹ The trend gained momentum in September, as active ETFs brought in $11 billion, seeing their best month of inflows this year.¹

More choice and managers in active ETFs

Some advisors may be interested in active strategies for specific asset classes, but their preferred active managers may not offer those strategies as ETFs. That could change, though, as more asset managers launch their first active ETFs in response to demand from investors and advisors.

For example, in the U.S. equity category, active ETFs have attracted inflows of $21.5 billion year to date.¹ Capital Group has already established itself as a competitive active ETF manager despite entering the space relatively recently in February 2022.²

What’s driving the interest in active equity ETFs? The benefits of the ETF structure, including tax efficiency and portfolio transparency, definitely contribute. More advisors may also be turning to actively managed strategies in the face of market volatility and the potential impact of rising inflation and interest rates on corporate profits. Meanwhile, more active managers are offering their strategies in the ETF vehicle that some advisors prefer.

Finally, the concentration issues in popular market-capitalization-weighted indexes have raised questions about the diversification of core passive equity ETFs. For example, the S&P 500 Index has about 32% in the top 10 stocks alone.³

Looking ahead, it appears advisors will have more options to select from in active ETFs. In 2022, there were 454 new ETFs launched and 64% of them active.¹ Active launches in 2023 are already on pace to top that figure, with active representing three quarters of all ETF launches so far.¹

Comparing passive and active ETFs
Key differences when considering index-tracking and actively managed ETFs

 

Advisors combine active and passive strategies

Some advisors use a mix of active and passive funds based on the particular asset class and the selection of ETFs currently available.

For the last several years, Capital Group’s Portfolio Consulting and Analytics team has worked with thousands of financial advisors on building investment portfolios. During this time, in the portfolios the team has analyzed, the amount of actively managed investments has remained consistently near 70%, with passive occupying approximately 30% of portfolios. For RIA portfolios specifically, that balance has hovered at 60% active and 40% passive.

In general, I believe advisors tend to prefer active strategies because of the ability to align portfolios with investment objectives such as preserving capital, generating income, and capital appreciation. Oftentimes, the use of passive is partially rooted in the benefits of the ETF vehicle, including lower costs, tax efficiency and transparency.

With more well-known active managers offering their equity and fixed income strategies in the ETF vehicle, we are eager to see how this impacts portfolio construction decisions by advisors.

Our suite of actively managed ETFs is growing. We recently introduced five new actively managed ETFs, including Capital Group’s first-ever multi-asset ETF.

¹ Source: Morningstar Direct, as of September 30, 2023.
² “8 Observations on ETF Flows in August,” Morningstar.com, September 1, 2023.
³ Source: S&P Dow Jones Indices, as of September 30, 2023.